Menendez Brothers’ Case: Prosecutors Recommend Resentencing For 1989 Murders
Election Day may person affected Erik Menendez and Lyle Menendez’s accidental astatine freedom.
Los Angeles County District Attorney George Gascón, who precocious shared his office’s determination to urge the brothers beryllium resentenced, mislaid his re-election Nov. 5 to erstwhile U.S. Assistant Attorney General Nathan Hochman. And the alteration successful District Attorney whitethorn signifier whether the bureau moves guardant with the case.
Although Hochman has not revealed his stance connected the brothers—who are presently serving beingness sentences without parole for the 1989 murders of their parents José Menendez and Mary Louise "Kitty" Menendez—he antecedently slammed Gascón for his determination to denote the adjacent steps weeks aft the Netflix bid Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story brought eyes backmost to the case. As Hochman said during an October debate, “The timing is incredibly suspicious.”
As for what Hochman—who whitethorn alternatively retreat the recommendation—would bash if elected? “I would get deep, heavy into the facts,” helium said during the L.A. Times and KNX News debate. “You would surely not person maine clasp a property league to archer you I’m conscionable reasoning astir it.”
Meanwhile, Gascón admitted the ways successful which the Ryan Murphy bid and consequent Menendez Brothers doc that followed expedited their hearing, which had initially been acceptable for Nov. 29.
“When a caller Netflix documentary came out, we instantly started getting bombarded with media requests and calls due to the fact that the lawsuit came backmost again to the surface,” helium explained of the hearing, which stemmed from a habeas petition filed by the brothers successful 2023. “The determination was made that alternatively than reply 1 media petition astatine a time, we would really conscionable travel retired and precise intelligibly accidental wherever we are.”
VINCE BUCCI/AFP via Getty Images
Gascón formerly announced his office’s proposal Oct. 24, 1 week aft the brothers’ lawyer Mark Geragos shared 2 caller pieces of grounds regarding the case, specifically related to the brothers’ allegations of intersexual maltreatment astatine the hands of their dad.
"There are radical successful the bureau that powerfully judge that the Menendez brothers should enactment successful situation the remainder of their life, and they bash not judge that they were molested," Gascón shared during the property conference. "And determination are radical successful the bureau that powerfully judge that they should beryllium released immediately, and that they were, successful fact, molested."
Although helium emphasized that helium did not privation their alleged maltreatment to “excuse” the killings, helium noted that “after a precise cautious reappraisal of each the arguments,” helium would taxable his recommendation.
California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation
His bureau yet recommended the brothers, who were convicted successful 1996, beryllium resentenced to 50 years successful situation with the anticipation for parole. And fixed they were nether 26 astatine the clip of the murders—Lyle was 21 and Erik was 18—if a justice signed disconnected connected the recommendation, they would beryllium eligible for parole immediately.
It was a bittersweet announcement for their loved ones, including Erik’s woman Tammi Menendez and Lyle’s woman Rebecca Sneed, who hoped for much leniency successful the case.
“Yesterday was a hard and affectional day,” Tammi wrote connected X, formerly known arsenic Twitter, Oct. 25. “I americium Grateful to DA Gascon for his courageousness to question re-sentencing for Erik. I americium people disappointed helium did not spell further and enactment connected his ain content that Erik and Lyle person served capable clip successful prison.”
As we await much updates connected Erik and Lyle’s case, their wives person continued to enactment them during their 3 decades successful prison. Read connected to larn much astir their relationships.
For the latest breaking quality updates, click present to download the E! News App