2 weeks ago
9
Why the Menendez Brothers Trial Is Worth Revisiting
"I burst into tears. I had to locomotion a agelong mode to spot him...when helium got brought implicit successful a van, I was capable to spot him coming disconnected and conscionable with him and I wasn't definite however I would react," Lyle Menendez said successful 2018, describing his emotional situation reunion with younger member Erik Menendez after 22 years apart.
"I conscionable felt a batch of adrenaline and just, I ended up bursting into tears," helium told DailyMailTV, "which is rather an affectional moment... conscionable fantastic arsenic you'd expect."
Finally, 1 of Lyle's half-dozen transportation requests had been granted that February, and two months later he was moved into the aforesaid lodging portion arsenic Erik at Richard J. Donovan Correctional Facility successful confederate San Diego County.
"I don't cognize that I truly ever recovered from [the separation]," Lyle said. "It's similar a healing of a coiled to beryllium reunited. It's been 25 years since the trials, I deliberation that's agelong enough."
Up until they were separated successful 1996 for what they thought mightiness beryllium forever, the siblings stressed that each they had was each other.
They also person their TikTok fans, a alternatively youthful assemblage (obviously) who discovered now-56-year-old Lyle and 53-year-old Erik online and started singing—or lip-syncing, specified arsenic to Britney Spears' "Criminal"—their enactment and full-on crushing connected trial-era Erik successful their videos.
"It's a batch of kids going back, watching Court TV, seeing however everything was portrayed, but looking astatine it with a caller acceptable of eyes and a antithetic acceptable of values," observed New York Times technology newsman Taylor Lorenz on an April 2021 occurrence of 20/20 astir the disturbing trend.
And yet different bid astir the Menendez brothers is coming retired Sept. 19, Ryan Murphy's Netflix anthology Monster choosing the execution of the siblings' parents for the follow-up to their Emmy-winning archetypal play astir serial slayer Jeffrey Dahmer.
Though it's not arsenic if Erik and Lyle didn't person their analog fans backmost successful the day, careless of what they did oregon wherefore they did it.
AP Photo/Nick Ut
What they did, astatine astir 10 p.m. on Aug. 20, 1989, was sprout their parents to decease successful the family's Beverly Hills mansion connected Elm Drive, a 9,000-square-foot Mediterranean-style location antecedently leased by the likes of Prince and Elton John before Jose Menendez and Mary Louise "Kitty" Menendez bought it little than a twelvemonth earlier the murders.
Jose, a 45-year-old amusement executive, was changeable point-blank successful the backmost of the head with a 12-gauge shotgun. He was recovered successful the den, wherever helium and Kitty, 47, his woman of 26 years, had been watching a movie. Kitty was recovered lying successful a excavation of humor successful the hallway, changeable successful the arms, thorax and face. Each was besides shot in the kneecap.
The brothers got successful the car and dumped the guns determination disconnected of Mulholland Drive, past threw the spent shotgun shells and their bloody apparel successful a dumpster astatine a state station. They bought movie tickets successful Century City for a movie they didn't see, past went to Santa Monica, wherever they tried to find 1 of Lyle's friends who could service arsenic an alibi; incapable to find the guy, they drove backmost home.
At 11:47 p.m., 21-year-old Lyle called 911, sobbing to the dispatcher, "Somebody killed my parents!"
The Menendez brothers told constabulary they'd gone to the movies to spot the latest Bond film License to Kill, but the enactment was excessively agelong truthful they saw Batman. Afterward, they said they went to the yearly "Taste of L.A." festival successful Santa Monica and past returned home, wherever they recovered their parents dead.
A bodyguard Lyle hired for astir 10 days later testified that his lawsuit said his parents were "murdered by either the cartel oregon the mob and helium was successful fearfulness for his life."
Google Maps
In the week instantly pursuing the killings, Lyle—a Rolex-sporting prep schoolhouse grad who had been suspended from Princeton for plagiarism—returned to New Jersey, wherever helium trial drove a Porsche (calling the Alfa Romeo helium had astatine location a "piece of s--t") and went shopping for clothes. He also enactment a put a $300,000 down outgo connected a edifice that specialized successful buffalo wings successful Princeton, N.J., wherever helium and Erik were born, aboriginal that year.
"'Well, I've been waiting truthful agelong to beryllium successful this position, that I'm prepared for it,'" Lyle said astatine his parents' wake, according to the grounds of pal and Princeton classmate Glenn Stevens.
When helium fired the bodyguard, Lyle told him he'd been assured by an uncle successful New York that the mob was nary longer retired to get their family.
During this time, 18-year-old Erik hired a backstage tennis manager and the brothers tooled astir L.A. successful their precocious mother's Mercedes convertible. They went to London and past to the Caribbean connected vacation. They rented a mates of penthouses successful Marina del Rey, Calif.
It was later said that the Menendez brothers blew done astir $1 cardinal successful six months. ("I don't deliberation it's understandable," Lyle aboriginal tried to explicate the spending spree to Barbara Walters. "People respond to it, to a traumatic lawsuit similar that, successful antithetic ways."
But the large interruption successful the lawsuit came from Erik himself.
The younger member ended up telling his psychologist, Dr. Jerome Oziel, connected Oct. 31 that he and Lyle killed their parents. Lyle joined them aboriginal that day, and Oziel recalled the older member being aggravated and menacing. Oziel met again with some brothers connected Nov. 2, and Lyle told the scientist that the brothers had talked astir sidesplitting him, the therapist testified.
It was Oziel's ex-girlfriend who ended up tipping disconnected the police. Oziel testified that, connected the nighttime of Oct. 31, helium went location and "told her what I needed to archer her."
AP Photo/Nick Ut
LAPD officers arrested Lyle connected March 8, 1990. Erik, playing tennis successful Israel astatine the time, surrendered upon returning to L.A. 3 days later.
And past the question of doctor-patient privilege helped clasp the lawsuit up for years. A justice ruled that, by threatening Oziel, Lyle had voided the brothers' close to confidentiality. The defense's entreaty was granted, past overturned by the California State Supreme Court, which re-allowed Oziel's tape-recorded notes, but not the confessions themselves, into evidence.
Lyle and Erik Menendez were indicted connected first-degree execution charges successful December of 1992. The L.A. County District Attorney's Office said it would seek the decease penalty.
Leslie Abramson headed up the defence for Erik, portion Jill Lansing was pb defence lawyer for Lyle.
Two years before the O.J. Simpson murder proceedings would go the astir talked astir proceedings of each time, prompting 24/7 media sum and a caller epoch for cablegram news, the Menendez brothers' archetypal execution trial—also televised beauteous overmuch successful its entirety connected Court TV—captivated the nation.
A self-made millionaire Cuban migrant and his quality queen wife, gunned down—according to prosecutors—by their 2 spoiled brat sons successful Beverly Hills: The lawsuit had each the trappings of a Hollywood melodrama (which it would go successful 1994, with Edward James Olmos and Beverly D'Angelo playing Jose and Kitty).
TriStar Television
The existent twist came, however, erstwhile the defence revealed its case: Lyle and Erik had acted in self-defense aft being sexually abused by their begetter for years. The brothers insisted they had feared for their lives.
Lyle testified in September 1993 that some parents sexually abused him, his begetter erstwhile helium was betwixt 6 and 8 years old. Kitty would bathe him and person him get into furniture with her up until helium was 13, helium said successful court, aft which she continued to "harass" him and beryllium inappropriate. His parents continued to beryllium convulsive with him into his precocious teens, Lyle said. When helium started dating, helium added, Kitty would telephone his girlfriends "gold diggers" and "bimbos."
One of the astir memorable pieces of testimony, 1 that made it into the TV movie, was Lyle's recollection of Kitty ripping disconnected his hairsbreadth portion during an statement 5 days before the murder. He claimed that was the archetypal clip Erik saw him without his toupee, aft which his younger member cried and revealed to him that Jose was inactive sexually abusing him, Lyle testified. (An ex-girlfriend of Lyle's, Jamie Pisarcik, would testify that Erik had talked astir Lyle wearing a hairpiece overmuch earlier that year. Pisarcik and Lyle reconciled aft his parents were killed, but she ended it successful December 1989 aft uncovering retired helium and his member were the killers, aft which she sold a ringing he'd fixed her and kept the cash. She besides testified that erstwhile Lyle told her astir the maltreatment successful a telephone telephone from jail, she said she didn't judge him.)
"I had dismissed what had happened to maine arsenic thing that happened to small boys," Lyle said successful court. Together, helium and Erik planned to face their dad.
When he warned Jose to permission Erik unsocial oregon he'd exposure him, their father replied, "'We each marque choices successful our life. Erik made his. You made yours,'" Lyle testified. The suspect added, "I thought we were successful danger. I felt helium had nary choice. He would termination us. He'd get escaped of america successful immoderate way. Because I was going to ruin him."
Asked wherefore they didn't spell to the police, Lyle said helium didn't judge they could assistance him due to the fact that "my dada is simply a affluent feline with a batch of power."
On the nighttime of Aug. 20, Kitty told them they couldn't spell to the movies and Jose told Lyle to hold unsocial successful his country upstairs. Convinced their parents were readying to termination them, they decided to onslaught first, Lyle testified. They grabbed the shotguns retired of their car, headed into the den and started blasting away.
Asked wherefore they didn't confess close distant erstwhile they were interviewed aboriginal the adjacent morning, Lyle said, "We had decided earlier that we wouldn't."
Without the assemblage present, Ozriel had told the court that the brothers seemed "immensely pleased with the excitement of pulling disconnected these...crimes without being caught."
Oziel past testified earlier the assemblage successful August 1993 that the brothers told him that they had planned to termination their begetter due to the fact that of his domineering ways, but realizing their parent would past beryllium a witness, decided to termination her too. (That July, the State Board of Psychology moved to revoke Oziel's licence implicit the unauthorized taping of the conversations and immoderate unrelated violations involving different patients.)
The brothers thought they had committed the "perfect crime," Oziel said connected the stand, relating however they had told him astir going backmost extracurricular to reload their guns arsenic their parent tried to crawl away.
The brothers were tried simultaneously but with abstracted juries—both of which ended up deadlocked astatine the extremity of the archetypal trial, incapable to hold connected whether Erik and Lyle were cold-blooded killers oregon tragic maltreatment victims.
After the archetypal trial, Abramson told reporters that the $14.5 cardinal property Lyle and Erik inherited had dwindled to astir thing and asked that acrophobic citizens donate to the Erik Menendez Legal Defense Fund for proceedings No. 2.
According to the Los Angeles Times in April 1994, probate records showed that determination was little than $700,000 successful currency left, successful summation to the family's Calabasas home, a condo successful New Jersey and immoderate furnishings and jewelry. Almost $4 cardinal had gone to taxes, portion different $4 cardinal went to upkeep and mortgages connected the Beverly Hills and Calabasas properties. Criminal defence fees magnitude to $1.495 cardinal astatine the time.
The brothers were backmost connected proceedings by August 1995 and, though the retrial was by each accounts overmuch much focused connected the gruesome transgression scene, arsenic the prosecution truly tried to hammer location conscionable however cruel these murders were, the proceedings played 2nd fiddle to the O.J. Simpson lawsuit playing retired crossed town.
Moreover, Judge Stanley Weisberg did not let cameras successful his Van Nuys courtroom, depriving the satellite of insider entree to circular two. Erik testified again, but Lyle did not.
AP Photo/Kevork Djansezian
And astatine the end of the 2nd trial, connected March 20, 1996, Lyle and Erik were some recovered blameworthy of two counts each of first-degree murder, with peculiar circumstances, and conspiracy to perpetrate murder. A assemblage decided to spare their lives during the penalty phase, recommending beingness successful situation without the anticipation of parole.
"Lyle is relieved due to the fact that helium wants to live," defence lawyer Charles Gessler told reporters aft proceeding the jury's decision.
"On the bully side, I would accidental that they're specified sizeable quality beings that they're going to find a mode to beryllium productive," added Abramson. "And successful information immoderate of the jurors were saying that too. It was their anticipation that they would some find a mode to lend to society."
"We did deliberation determination was intelligence maltreatment to immoderate extent. I deliberation astir of america believed that," juror Lesley Hillings told the LA Times afterward. "Sexual abuse? I don't deliberation we'll ever cognize if that's existent oregon not."
Abramson ended up accused of misconduct during the punishment signifier erstwhile a psychiatrist enlisted by the defence to conscionable with Erik claimed that she had asked him to exclude accusation from his league notes. She was cleared by the California Bar successful 1999.
After they fatally changeable their parents and sat done 2 trials together, their lives hanging successful the balance, the authorities of California opted to abstracted the Menendez brothers, sending Erik to Folsom State Prison (he was aboriginal transferred to Pleasant Valley State Prison) and Lyle to Mule Creek State Prison successful Ione.
The brothers' past memorable quality unneurotic was a jailhouse interview they gave to Barbara Walters which aired June 28, 1996, conscionable a fewer days earlier they were formally sentenced. Erik insisted, "I'm conscionable a mean kid," prompting a bemused effect from Walters.
"I was terrified that [the jury] would springiness either 1 of america death...It's scary," Erik said. Lyle said it was "very important" to them that they get to enactment unneurotic successful prison. "That is what has gotten america done these past six years, and done our life," helium said.
"What we did is awful, and I privation I could spell back..." Erik acknowledged. "We volition walk the remainder of our beingness successful prison. But if I'm not with--but if we're not enactment successful the aforesaid prison, there's a bully probability I volition ne'er spot him again and that...that I...there are immoderate things you cannot instrumentality and determination are immoderate things you tin endure. With everything taken away, [that would be] the past happening you tin take."
ABC
Asked astir the communal nationalist cognition that helium and his member were monstrous spoiled brats, Erik said, "That's not who I am, but I can't support that. Because I came from a household of wealth, that doesn't marque maine spoiled."
"I would beryllium amazed if anybody who was contiguous astatine the proceedings and saw the full thing, alternatively than snippets connected the news, would consciousness that," Lyle added.
And yet the 12 radical who mattered sent them disconnected to situation for the remainder of their lives. An appellate court upheld the convictions successful February 1998, and petitions for reappraisal were besides denied that May.
But 34 years aft the murders, the lawsuit is backmost successful the quality arsenic much allegations of enactment maltreatment leveled against their father—as good arsenic a missive unearthed successful 2023 that was purportedly written by Erik successful 1988 detailing Jose's abuse—have near ineligible experts wondering whether there's a way to get the brothers retired of prison.
Attorneys filed a habeas corpus petition connected the brothers' behalf successful May 2023, arguing that Erik's missive and erstwhile Menudo subordinate Ray Rosselló's accusation of rape against Jose (made successful the Peacock documentary Menendez + Menudo: Boys Betrayed) contradicted the prosecutions' contention astatine proceedings that Erik and Lyle were motivated by greed.
The brothers' filing, which included a declaration from Rosselló, asked the L.A. County D.A.'s Office to unfastened an evidentiary proceeding oregon vacate the convictions and sentences.
"The shootings were not execution but manslaughter," the petition reads, "committed retired of an honorable though unreasonable content successful the request for self-defense aft a beingness of intersexual and carnal abuse."
The D.A.'s Office told the L.A. Times successful mid-July 2023 that they were inactive reviewing the lawsuit files earlier submitting immoderate effect to the judge.
Meanwhile, Lyle said successful 2017 that helium felt much "at peace" successful situation than helium ever did connected the outside.
"It's shocking to think...that I could person been progressive successful taking anyone's life—and my parents' life," Lyle told ABC News by telephone from Mule Creek for the 2-hour special Truth and Lies: The Menendez Brothers—American Sons, American Murderers, which aired that January. "It seems unimaginable due to the fact that it seems truthful acold removed from who I am. But I recovered that my ain puerility prepared maine amazingly good for the chaos of situation life."
He continued, "I americium the kid that did termination his parents, and nary stream of tears has changed that and nary magnitude of regret has changed it. I judge that. You are often defined by a fewer moments of your life, but that's not who you are successful your life, you know. Your beingness is your totality of it...You can't alteration it. You just, you're stuck with the decisions you made...I deliberation I volition extremity up dying inactive being successful the nightmare of this horrifying lawsuit and tragedy."
Oxygen
But not everyone thinks he's a monster. Lyle joined erstwhile exemplary Anna Eriksson connected July 2, 1996, the time helium was sentenced to beingness successful prison; they divorced successful 2011 aft helium was reportedly caught "cheating" (writing letters to different woman). He wed Rebecca Sneed successful 2003.
Incidentally, California does not let conjugal visits for prisoners convicted of execution and/or serving beingness sentences.
Chris Morton/Online USA
Erik besides joined successful June 1999, uncovering emotion with azygous ma Tammi Ruth Saccoman, who had been penning to him since his archetypal trial.
"Not having enactment successful my beingness is difficult, but it's not a occupation for me," Saccoman, who penned the 2005 publication They Said We'd Never Make It: My Life With Erik Menendez, told People that year. "I person to beryllium physically detached, and I'm emotionally attached to Erik... My household does not understand. When it started to get serious, immoderate of them conscionable threw up their hands."
Erik said at the clip that he didn't consciousness helium deserved to beryllium successful situation for the remainder of his life.
"I'm not saying what I did was close oregon justifiable," helium told People in 2005 with Saccoman by his side. "I needed to spell to prison. But spot different kid successful my beingness and spot what happens. I felt it was either my beingness oregon my parents' life. It's arsenic if determination was kerosene each implicit the level that a lucifer could airy astatine immoderate time. And my psyche was burnt to death."
Erik said helium felt helium deserved to spell to prison, but "I don't judge that I merit to beryllium here. And I whitethorn good get retired of situation 1 day. I americium inactive moving connected my appeal. I don't cognize if that is realistic. But the decease of anticipation is the decease of the heart. I can't deliberation astir it. If I was serving immoderate bully intent successful being present for life, past I could accidental it was the close thing. But I'm not."
He said helium had work The Power of Now astatine slightest 15 times, helium meditated regular and he had spent the past 14 years building his relationship with God.
During his archetypal twelvemonth successful prison, however, helium was excessively acrophobic to effort to talk to God.
"But I could speech with my mother," Erik said. "She inactive loved me. I would emotion maine if I was her. After this forgiving signifier I was capable to admit my parent again successful my life."
(E! and NBC are some members of the NBCUniversal family.)
(A erstwhile mentation of this communicative was primitively published April 25, 2017, at 4 a.m. PT)
English (US) ·